Top 2: Why can't singers sing for THEMSELVES!!??

Submitted by zappa on 16 October, 2006 - 5:08pm.

Okay, here's my 5 cents worth...

I am at a loss to explain why, oh why, singers can't sing because they want to!? It seems that they (including the top 3) are forever saying things like "I'm in NZ Idol because my partner/mother/grand-dad/dog/cousin..." would be proud of me.

Hell, sing because you want to Idols - stop this pretence about doing it for other people.

»

Sir Barney 18 October, 2006 - 5:57am
If it doesn't kill you, you've failed.

Maybe they are doing it for themselves but ALSO for their koro/aunty/mum/friend because thats what makes them more determined?

Maybe not.

admin 18 October, 2006 - 8:20am

Barney how much did you pay Stables to mention you on the show this year? Laughing out loud

Loyal 17 October, 2006 - 11:30am
www.daughtryofficial.com

I always think that.  Thought it when Matt said right at the beginning he was doing it for his son - what does his son know about it?  Why was Aroha singing for her Grandad?

Why weren't they there singing because they actually wanted to have a singing career and this is a way of helping them to make it.  So who in the top 10 actually auditioned for that reason?

Ben for sure, one of the reasons I wished  him luck, even if he wasn't one of my favourite singers.  Becks too.  Probably Toni, and Kali. Definately Victor.

lucky 16 October, 2006 - 10:45pm

We all know they are in it this year to win the $50,000.00 and the 4WD it's probably the best thing they will get out of being the NZ Idol. The trouble with NZ is they don't promote the winners of NZ Idol. After they release their single we never get to see them on TV anymore. In Australia the Idol winners go on to be very successful with the exception of Cassie. The contestants on Australian Idol like Guy Sebastian, Shannon Noll, Paulini, Cosima, Anthony do well in the music industry and continue to sing at important events.

sharrie 16 October, 2006 - 5:41pm

hehehe......well said zappa......touche...agree completely

Starshone 16 October, 2006 - 5:38pm
http://myspace.com/ariacaro

Okay, so I shouldn't have a sob story next year?

TuiKiwi 16 October, 2006 - 5:13pm
Can't beat the old IB days

I agree: Its getting boring. Just about every idol this year has a sob story.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

My discussions

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 16 guests online.