General: Elton John Show Chatroom

Submitted by admin on 17 September, 2006 - 8:33pm

Chat is in here tonight due to technical issues with the other chatroom.

hhhmmmmkk, 2nite was such a

hhhmmmmkk, 2nite was such a dissapointment, just like last week, but betta not mention that again coz then il get really upset haha... anyways becks didnt do as well last night but she soooooooooooooo didnt deserve to leave!!! toni has really really got to go!!!gosh seriously newzealand!

why was indira in the bottom 2????????????? f**kn crazy!!!! she has realy really got 2 win, matt and indira are the best by far and it betta be them 2 going for the gold 4 the final!! and i think aroha's really good 2 but i agree with the judges that shes just gotta get in2 it a lil more.

but i still think the best idol eevvvvveeeeeeerrrrrrr waaassss...... steve broad lol : )

Can't see any threads about

Can't see any threads about indivuidual Elton John songs.  So will say what I thought about all of them here.

First of all, thought it was a very diappointing night overall.

Indira was OK.  Don't know why, just didn't stand out for me, though I expected her singing that song would. Think she's very much like Rosita

Ben just bopped around smiling and looking 'cute' as always.  Doing nothing different or memorable. Just went on and on. Definately a very inferior voice against all the others.

Kali was a bit better than last week.  But, nothing special or particularly good. Just sung and moved around much she always does.

Again liked the sound of Aroha singing, though did pick up something not right with her voice.  Sounded nasely, but explained at the end.   So she did do a very good job of singing after all.   But again, no emotion or feeling in it.

Becks a big disappointment.  Why did she sing that song?  Did nothing for here.  Almost as if she isn't making any real effort any more. 

Always enjoy listening to and watching Matt - and this night was no exception.  He sound good and always puts such feleing into his face and voice.

The best though definately Toni again! Loved every moment of her performance, and she looked really nice too.

I Dunno how you guys

I Dunno how u guys felt...but this show was jus totally boring!..i mean with country last week then this 1 was just pathetic, hopefully nxt weeks..'Groove' show is better!....And I have a feeling that Some 1 really talented is going to get eliminated tonight!because we havent had a shock elimination yet!i can feel it coming upon us...I hate to say it But I think Indira may get cut 2night...*Sob*Sob*

What's with the dumb themes

What's with the dumb themes this year? What happened to good old My Generation, KiwiAna etc.

Pop and Kiwi are coming up

Pop and Kiwi are coming up :)

Hey Rach, do you think this

Hey Rach, do you think this season is as good as last year? Honestly..

Country week was better than

Country week was better than last year's themes. Rock and Elton week sucked this year.

mate seriously... really not

mate seriously... really not a cool theme for idol.  seems like the girls had a real hard time tonight!

Well Matt is the ONLY

Well Matt is the ONLY performer tonight to both sing well and perform well. Kali sang quite well and performed quite well. The rest all sucked big time!!!

Does anyone else think it is quite seriously bad, that at this stage of the competition, this is the best we have?

ooooohhhh! Matt was crappy!!

ooooohhhh! Matt was crappy!! Sooooooooo boring!!  Aroha...Please!! YAAAWNNN. Toni  was awesome... Ben rocked...AGAIN... Indira GOOO Girl!! TOP THREE TONIGHT...!

Twas a boring show. Should

Twas a boring show. Should have done my homework instead :s

I agree.

I agree.

Frankie needs to learn to

Frankie needs to learn to sing another tune!! 

All the comments about theatre are wearing very thin!

Kali and Bex arent allowed to emote yet toni is and aroha is told she needs to!

Time he made up his mind, frankly (pun intended) sick to death of judges playing favourites rather than letting the evenings performances stand for themselves.

Several Idols have been sick over the series but there hasnt been excuses made for them. Kali clearly best vocal performance of night along with toni so its about time the judges cut her a break and get over her theatre training!

Totally agree its just

Totally agree its just starting to get god damn confusing.  You cant possibly emote a song better then what Kali did tonight.

Last week Kali just stood still and got no theatre comments, bottom 2?

Kali just keep doing your thing

agree

agree

I think tonight was boring

I think tonight was boring because it was all ballads except for Ben

Bottom 2: Becks and Aroha

So how'd you like ballads

So how'd you like ballads week on Idol 1?

Didn't watch Idol 1, but I

Didn't watch Idol 1, but I should probably rephrease my comment to ballads performed with no real emotion that made an excellent opportunity to go make a cup of tea.

With Love Songs last year, I was glued to my TV, this year all these half-assed ballads just bored me. And I'm a big Elton fan!

Mmmmmm tea. Now I feel like

Mmmmmm tea. Now I feel like tea.

bottom 2, Matt and Kali

bottom 2, Matt and Kali

I didnt like that show one

I didnt like that show one little bit

Ewwwwwww in general

I LOVED THAT "Stables does

I LOVED THAT

"Stables does have a lot of responsibility tonight, doesn't he? He's sitting in Megan's seat...!"

New poll is up.

New poll is up.

Yes she has the voice!!

Yes she has the voice!!

Toni pwns again

Toni pwns again

Get your words right girl

Get your words right girl

Oh yeah Toni - she's doin it

Oh yeah Toni - she's doin it just great - safe as houses gggirl xxxxxxxx

I love Toni's emotions when

I love Toni's emotions when she sings.

thats even slower than EJ

thats even slower than EJ :(

Why didnt toni do her hair

Why didnt toni do her hair tonight?

Har, Voldemort's in Maid of

Har, Voldemort's in Maid of Manhattan.

Im glad frankie pulled Matt

Im glad frankie pulled Matt up about the woo and hands etc.

im connecting with the audience?? Lol

i was cracking up at the cross eyed facials at the end :P

"I just do ['whoo!'] to

"I just do ['whoo!'] to connect with the audience!"

GAHAH!

GAHAH!

I would have enjoyed a

I would have enjoyed a Britney Spears theme more than this.

*shudder* AND 'SHONE! DON'T

*shudder* AND 'SHONE! DON'T USE L337 LANGUAGE!

1337 PWNS J00.

1337 PWNS J00.

my op.. Elton John theme has

my op.. Elton John theme has been the worse! even gangster rap wouldve been better

i definately thought it

i definately thought it would be better - what is the theme next week admin?

Don't know yet but will let

Don't know yet but will let people know when I do. It could be love songs.

OMG A BRITNEY THEME WOULD

OMG A BRITNEY THEME WOULD HAVE PWNED XD

what is pwned xd?

what is pwned xd?

Pwned-adjctv. [Own-d] To

Pwned-adjctv. [Own-d] To pwn; to be so good nothing else comparable is better.

*giggle* I've explained XD

*giggle* I've explained XD to you before Sir B :P

I find matt boring and i

I find matt boring and i wouldnt a) go to his concert, b) take notice if i heard him on the radio, or c) buy his album

CHUR COUZZ!! high notes and

CHUR COUZZ!! high notes and power!!

He does that "woo!" every

He does that "woo!" every time and Frankie calls him out on it.

Ok no-one has impressed me

Ok no-one has impressed me tonight..man what a bad show this is turning out to be..

Exactly - none stood out and

Exactly - none stood out and it was really boring overall.

it really IS Boring..what a

it really IS Boring..what a waste of my time!!!

My discussions