TV/Movies: TV2 vs TV3's new celeb singing comps

Submitted by admin on 14 September, 2005 - 4:06pm.

Which (if either) will you be watching?

TV2: So you wanna be a popstar

OR

TV3: Sing like a superstar

Which will be the better produced show?

Which has the better celebs?

TV2: Mikey Havoc, Louise Wallace, John 'Cocksy' Cocks, David Wikaira-Paul, Jessie Gurunathan Blair Strang Katrina Hobbs

OR

TV3: Karl Burnett Eroni Clarke Jon Bridges Siobhan Marshall Carolyn Taylor Marina McCartney Nicko Vella Mike Puru Mark Hewlett Amber Peebles Evie Ashton Sarah Bradley

Which has the better hosts?

TV2: Oliver Driver

OR

TV3: Petra Bagust and Simon Barnett?

»

cantdecide 18 September, 2005 - 7:41pm
BRYAN/BRYAN WON!! XD

TV3's show'll be coming out first; it'll definitely be more popular. They also have more contestants, and younger, more well-known celebrities. ^_^

hideousrockboy 21 September, 2005 - 9:01am
Get out of my car!!

True!

Jemma 18 September, 2005 - 7:41pm
Luvzy//

MARIANNE! Sticking out tongue

Yeah I think TV3 will be more popular too. Smiling

Mum-Kun 18 September, 2005 - 7:34pm

Most of the TV2 'celebrities' are famous for nothing...

Given a choice, TV3. Interesting how a few of the TV3 contestants are from TV2 originally (Caro Taylor, Mike Puru, Evie Ashton).

Know what? I'd rather just play Singstar.

Jacob 20 September, 2005 - 4:58pm

Evie Ashton was a 3 News presenter/reporter before she ever went to Flipside, and she is now back at CanWest again on the radio as well as TV

DevilDodo 18 September, 2005 - 1:55pm

Anyone else seriously considering selling their tv?

idoltery 18 September, 2005 - 1:51pm

Better host: Oliver Driver

David Wikaira Paul in TV2 should be good.  Louise Wallace is over-done.

SoulPatrolBaby 16 September, 2005 - 1:01am

i dont even no half those people lol

hams_coconut 15 September, 2005 - 11:43pm
>>Lavina Williams should have won Australian

id have tv 3 hosts with one half of tv2 contestants and one half of tv3's!!

then id mix the shows together!!

mix it in a bowl

throw it in the oven for 30 minutes on high and you have a perfect show!!

MattyJ 15 September, 2005 - 1:15pm

Yes, I must admit that TV3 seems to be putting a real good show together. It's pop, not "pop".

Doubletake 15 September, 2005 - 12:35pm

The TV2 one sounds just AWFUL!!!!  LOL and it's up against Bro Town.  No question as to which one I'm watching.

 I'd rather have a Superstar rather than the washed-up TV2 has-been like the ones on their show. Didn't Paul Holmes want to be a Popstar once? 

From what I've heard Mike Puru going on about in the mornings on The Edge, it sounds like he's have a great laugh in rehearsals so I think it will be fun.

I still can't believe that TV2 is ripping off TV3.

Jacob 15 September, 2005 - 12:09am

I HATE JOHN COCKS!

with a passion...

Nellie old account 15 September, 2005 - 12:12am

So do I.

He was such an ass on Treasure Island, both times.

Jacob 24 September, 2005 - 3:49am

exactly, i hate treasure island now, its just getting old

penname 21 September, 2005 - 11:36am

Agree 100%. He think he's the cat's pyjamas and the bee's knees rolled into one.

Cam (not verified) 14 September, 2005 - 11:43pm

definitley tv3's.

Texas 14 September, 2005 - 9:58pm
People are difficult to govern because they have t

TV2's lineup is boring and Cocksy ARGGG. They should get the Informercial Queen of NZ because her accent is so funny.

Jacob 14 September, 2005 - 7:07pm

TVNZ has now resorted to copying TV3's ideas for shows?!?!

That is just pathetic...

I would rather watch the TV3 Sing Like A Superstar anyway, it looks far better!

Kimmeh 14 September, 2005 - 5:53pm
I have an e-pal from England :cool:

I'd rather watch TV3...

Cocksy is on everything... they need some new people... :s

WgTn_GuRl 14 September, 2005 - 5:51pm
Rubber Ducky

i think tv3 will be better

admin 14 September, 2005 - 4:24pm

Can I just say TV2's celebs are embarrassing.

Mikey Havoc - already has had a music career and a #1 single (Push it!) He looks nothing like a "popstar".

Louise Wallace - ugh she looks nothing like a "popstar".

John 'Cocksy' Cocks - reality TV show celeb celeb. Need I say more? And looks like a "popstar"?

David Wikaira-Paul - already does lots of music gigs. Most likely to win, of the guys because he's the youngest.

Jessie Gurunathan - could look like a "popstar", but *yawn*.

Blair Strang - too many woman's mags for me :S

Katrina Hobbs - too old to be a "popstar".

Robyn 14 September, 2005 - 6:56pm

Mikey Havoc's band was Push Push and their massive hit single was "Trippin'" ("I was trippin' out on yeeeew!")

He'll certainly be very entertaining, but TV3's line-up is certainly more intriguing.

I have to say I am far more interested in seeing Karl Burnett sing than Louise Wallace.

As long as they aren't scheduled opposite each other, I will endevour to watch both.

hideousrockboy 18 September, 2005 - 1:15pm
Get out of my car!!

Go Mikey and Push Push! Lol ... I remember that Laughing out loud

anjelus 14 September, 2005 - 6:51pm
IB Advisory Clinic

Katrina Divine made Blair do the magazines.  

flirty_skirty 2 October, 2005 - 4:29pm
Reppin Te Insane Skirt Posse

Of course you know this because your sister's friend's brother's girlfriend introduced you to him! And, now he's single you are chasing him?

(from memory, I think that is how it goes)

X 14 September, 2005 - 5:42pm

Blair's down at law school, lol.

Mr Phantomb 14 September, 2005 - 4:16pm
www.troubleintahiti.com

TV3 all the way.

But I didn't watch Dancing With the Stars so I don't think I'll bother watching celebrities averagely warble out songs.

DevilDodo 14 September, 2005 - 4:11pm

These shows just make me want to cry...

Sinead 14 September, 2005 - 4:11pm
[siné]

yeah i'd probably watch both or neither... on saying that im more likely to watch tv2 cause the tv3 reception in my room isnt the best... but i think i prefer the tv3 celebs (im sick of cocksy)... dunno *shrugs*

i think its pretty pathetic that they both have practically the same kind of show on at the same time...

Jem. 14 September, 2005 - 4:08pm
I have awards in playdough sculpting

Depending when they're on I'll probably watch both of them. Sticking out tongue

EDIT// LMAO! I wrote something that idolblog didn't like and so it said

Depending when they're on I'll probably watch both of them. Sticking out tongue
I'm such a tv

But what I was really trying to say, was that I was a tv "insert word Idolblog didn't like here".

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

My discussions

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 26 guests online.