1. Rongo
2. Nik
3. Kashia
4. Steven
5. Rosita
6. Frank
7. Jesse
8. Teresa
9. Shelly
10. Ashley
This is on Performance not neccessarily the Best Voice. Looking at whole package
NZ Idol 2: Rate Top 10 Performers to the bottom Performer in Top 10
American Idol Finalists: Brandon Rogers, Sundance Head, Chris Richardson, Blake Lewis, Phil Stacey, Chris Sligh, Jared Cotter, Sanjaya Malakar, Jordin Sparks, Stephanie Edwards, Sabrina Sloan, Melinda Doolittle, Antonella Barba, Lakisha Jones, Gina Glocksen, Haley Scarnato
Throng | NZ TV Guide | Television Guide | Throng | TV Throng | American Idol | Australian Idol | Canadian Idol | NZ Idol | Shortland Street | Beijing Olympic Games
blog design by cre8d and hosted by Optimum
Who will win American Idol? | American Idol Tour | American Idol Winner | voting numbers | American Idol Links
Hard Luck Shelly
1. Rongo
2. Keshia
3. Nik
Rongo ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!
To all those HATERS out there.......
I think all your opinions dont mean anything u are all just jealous if u dont have nething good to say then dont say nething at all. its an awesum achievement to make it as far as ne of the top 10 contestants have regardless of their voices.
i say big ups to all the contestants im not a fan of all the voices but it cant be easy performing on tv, ide assume most of the contestants have never done nething this big b4. GO NZ IDOL TOP 10!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Go and bury a bone or something.
Having an opinion does not mean that anyone is jealous...
So what you're saying is, people shouldn't have criticised Hitler and opposed him, because "if you dont have nething good to say then dont say nething at all" in your oh so knowledgable words?
Fool. We are entitled to our opinions. We are also entitled to express them. Learn the difference between hate and criticism.
*anything
*awesome
*don't
1. Nik
2. Ashley
3. Rongo
4. Keshia
5. Jesse
6. Theresa
7. Steven
8. Frank
9. Shelley
10. Rosita
Hmmm..*thinks about this*
1. Keshia
2. Nik
3. Rosita
4. Jesse
5. Teresa
6. Rongo
7. Frank
8. Ashley
9. Shelly
10. Steven
Dam people, its getting hot in here! I think nursecandy needs to take all of your temperatures and give you all chill pills...all the contestents have their individual merits, and their downfalls. Idol isn't about who is the best singer or performer, it is about who the public (mostly teenage girls) vote for. But we have to do the best with what we have. And the best to worst are in this order:
1. Keshia
2. Nik - these two have the best vocal ability, they just need to get rid of the nerves, I'd rather buy a CD with a decent vocal sound, you can't see them on CD, and we haven't seen enough of them yet to know whether they have the goods on stage. Wait till they have a live band and more of a stage and choreography and vibe to work with.
3. Teresa - she needs to open her eyes a bit more, and think wisely about song choice, but she has got a quality not many, if any, of the other top 10 have
4. Rosita
5. Jesse
6. Frank
7. Rongo
8. Shelley
9. Steven - Steven from Dunedin would have been a better choice.
10. Ashley - what the!!! How she bet Lissel is an indication of the voters in this country, proves the point that people don't make the top 10 on vocal ability. Very average indeed.
hehe
hehe! Ashley might just prove you wrong!
Nursecandy I couldn't put them in order (just top and bottom group), but you have done it nicely for me. I'd agree with most of your choices (and don't know which I don't agree with
)
How do you know Steven from Dunedin???
Aww thanks Ahmad....
Steven from Dunedin is famous haha I listen to The Edge now and then and hear him on there, are you related? I think he is an albino Indian like me
My top 3 choices are Nik Teresa and Keshia. I think Teresa's voice is the most unique and she will always do well...no matter what.
I hope she wins...but I think maybe Nik has the whole Idol package goin for him. But, haven't we had enough of that whole look.
Teresa would be unique and gr8!!!
1) Keshia 2)Nik 3) Ashley 4) Teresa 5) Jesse 6) Rosita 7) Rongo 8 ) Stephen 9) Frank 10) Shelley
1. Keshia
2. Nik
3. Jesse
4. Teresa
5. Ashley
6. Rongo
7. Rosita
8. Steven
9. Frank
10. Shelly
teresa's eyes are fine as they are with that dreamy look.
1Nik
2Keshia
3Rongo
4Jesse
NZ idol is all about votes and Id say these would be the top 4. Hard to say about the rest. Thou, I would be absolutely over the moon if Rongo won.
VOTE RONGO ALL THA WAY, HE HAS THA WHOLE PACKAGE, NO DOUBT HE WILL EVOLVE AS A PERFORMER AND PICK UP THE LITTLE THINGS HE HAS YET TO GRASP, AND THEN THERE WILL BE NOTHING LEFT FOR HIM TO DO BUT SUCSEED!!! SHOT BRO, GO HARD, WE ALL SUPPORT YOU AND WE ALL TRUST IN YOU!!!! KIA KAHA BRO!!!
What kind of seed?
And how hard will he suck?
Rongo can suck a golfball through.....er...anyway.
I've heard pumpkin seeds are good for sucking.
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz boring, jealous, comment. Thats all it boils down to. Rongos fans must have got to you aye. mwaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!! Your so funny Phantombum. Thats ok. Big kissess to you from a fan of RONGO xxxxx.
or a mango pip
1. teresa
2. Nik
3. Ashley
sorry but i think everyone else is pretty average.
1. Teresa - She looks great, sings amazingly. I dont mind her hand movements
2. Kesia - She's got everything going for her. Maybe let her nerves in too much.
3. Nik - Good performer, but not as unique as Teresa and Kesia. Probably perfect for NZ Idol though.
4. Jesse - Great singer, cool personality. Can't move to well though.
5. Rosita - Voice that sings and sings well.
6. Ashley - Got the shle package, but not much X factor.
7. Frank - Cool performer, but same problem as Ashley.
8. Rongo - Great look, but singing aint up to scratch.
9. Stephen - Average.
10. Shelley - How she got in over Lissel, I'll never know. She is boring to watch and boring to listen to.
On performance not voice:
All the rest cannot be ordered because they are far below Ashley's performance ability.
All the rest (from memory... squeaze me if my memory has failed me) stood on the spot, made some odd hand movements, and did practically not much else.
Rongo??
Look at the whole package....
I am, he might not have the best singing voice, but his voice is still good. His personality when singing surpasses all. He shows emotion and character in his ablilty to captivate the audience with his performing. How many other peopl ein this competition do you reackon can do that. Sure now Teresa cant. If nik put more life behind his performance he would be the man. Whakaarongo ki to korero Ahmad.
In hindsight my comments were harsh. You were merely expressing an opinion, and I was expressing mine. Rongo is nowhere near in the league of Teresa, in my opinion, and that's cool that you disagree
Peace
um.....1.nik
2.keshia
3.rosita....but really my no.1 idol will always be MARINO even if he isnt still in nz idol coz there are plenty more opportunities and im sure hes gona be BIG some day!!!
Maori_boy - if you know Rongo personally, then please make sure he sings the right songs.....i like his personality and his voice is good also - just lacks a little confidence. I'm backing the maori boy for this one, and all he needs to do is make the right song choices.....GO RONGO!!!
Teresa to be the first to go!
I'm sure there are many people that would be prepared to eat an idolblog sticker if Teresa was the first to go!
Caught up with him the other day. Lol Everyones giving him the same advice. Hope he listens
I have some advice you can give him. "Sing in tune". It's a great place to start...
E ki RA!! Bey you dont know nudda. He did sing in tune. Just cause your deaf
Settle down, I wasn't being rude, I thought it was good advice for him. I remember thinking his first audition for the judges was really good, but he was most definitely out of tune in the top 24 round. If he wants to go all the way he'll need more votes than just ones from obsessive family and friends, so he would be wise to sing better.
I hate to say this but some Rongo fans can't spell. Maybe you guys should go back to primary before insulting us.
<>and once again Death_Wish you look to insult the person?! Here's advice for some: I think Teresa's fans should invest in hearing aids..........cos SHE CAN'T BLOODY SING!!!!!!!!!
Here's advice for most Rongo fans, you guys should buy EAR PLUGS......because HE CAN'T BLOODY SING!!!!!
P.S. Ear Plugs from Trade Me only cost $13, get it while it's cheap!!!
You really like the sound of your own voice - or look of your own posts - don't you?
"Hello Kettle? It's Pot!"
Even better $2 shop. lol. But he sounds good to me.
I hope you know that by sinking to their level, you look just as stupid as they do.
We know you love Teresa, but maybe you should spend your time chatting to other Teresa fans instead of defending her against people who are just getting their kicks out of your retaliation.
hmmmmmmm, maybe you're right Nellie. Thanks for the advice.
It's all good
POOH
it's called texting in idolblog hehee!
Yus!
I've been waiting a long long time to hear easitman crack out his patented "heehee!" again.
thanx phantomb heehee!