Not long now till we find out three more contestants to go through to the Top 10! Will it be Nik, Teresa and either Jesse or Rongo? Looks very close for third place but then again, anything can happen!
Dom welcomes us back and we see them all sitting on the couches.
Maselina is grouped with Nik.
Clark is grouped with Teresa.
Rongo is grouped with Makuini.
Malia is grouped with Jesse.
Dom makes a joke about paulellis.com. We get to see a recap of last night's show.
Paul thinks Jesse, Nik and Teresa are going through.
Jackie thinks Nik, Teresa and Maselina.
Frank thinks Nik, Teresa, Malia.
Nik is going through, bye bye Maselina.
Rongo is going through, goodbye Makuini.
Teresa is going through, see ya Clark.
Jesse or Malia?
There's a new "natural moment" - "nasty judges" comments. We are, erm, graced with Liz Shaw again and the voodoo girl.
Fourth person in the Top 4: Jesse
Into the Top 10: Nik, Jesse and RONGO!
I dont lyk Rongo
I dont lyk Rongo
Why did Theresa miss out
Why did Theresa miss out when she seemed like such a sure thing?
Was it simply the huge family/hometown fanbase Rongo had?
Or was there something about Theresa that meant people just didn't warm to her?
I wonder what other stuff Theresa would sing if she had got into the top ten...
I think it was her song that made her performance more than anything. I wonder how versatile she is.
Perhaps subconsciously everyone else thought that as well.
Or maybe I should stop trying to be Freud.
Its because he was totally
Its because he was totally fantastic and was awesome!!!!!! Teresa was gud but Rongo was excellent!!!!!!!!!!!
YEP I AGREE WID DAT.......
YEP I AGREE WID DAT.......
Really? I just don't see
Really? I just don't see that: he was boring.
Teresa would have added a different element to the competition.
And btw, can you please refrain from using bold text unless you are highlighting certain words? It is rude, and distracting.
The problem with NZ being so
The problem with NZ being so small is that communities matter in the vote, much more than in much larger population bases like Aussie or the US. If you have a whole big community or group rooting for you, you're going to do well.
Big surprise last night:
Big surprise last night: Rongo gets in and Teresa is consigned to the *wildcards! Looking at the comments many including myself are surprised that she did not automatically go through to the top 10. While this may 'suck' to a lot of us, 'at the end of the day' it was still a 'legit' result under the existing 'NZ Idol' system of voting. However as others have already noted perhaps the real problem lays within the system of voting (for the selection of the Top 10).
Here, having just 1 vote to cast forces everyone to select the 'best' performer they think should go through to the next round. Clearly Rongo and Nik have already built up a strong following. Yet based upon her performance on Sunday, Teresa impressed many as "deserving to go through to the Top 10" including probably many from the respective camps of Rongo and Nik. However with only 1 vote to cast, people made sure that their no.1 contender was nominated. A No.2 such as Teresa therefore missed out.
A rational outcome? Yes. Fair under the 'rules'? Yes. Fair? No!
Solution? For the selection of the Top 10 (only) allow people to vote for a 'top 3' for the night. This will allow people to not only vote for their no.1 contender but also allow them to select performers whom they'd also like to remain in the competition. As we know from last year's Top 10 competition, the Top 10 is a fickle environment e.g. the rapid demise of Robin; a contender who came in with a large fanbase of support. So perhaps a change in the voting system might allow 'talent' a better chance to prove itself against 'popularity'.
BTW: Nik has both.
The voting system is a
The voting system is a crock. We shouldn't have to pay 99c PER VOTE, and be able to vote more than once at all. I said to my wife last night I would stop watching NZ Idol if Teresa didn't get through to the Top 10. I'm not sure if I'll carry through (probably not), but I won't be in a good mood for the rest of the season.
Teresa has an amazing voice, and Sunday's performance was incredible. This is a SINGING competition after all (well actually CORRECTION, this is a "who wants to pay the most to see their favourite go through popularity contest").
Its no point in saying how
Its no point in saying how disapointing it was that Teresa didnt get in. Her fans should've voted more. TERESAS fans should have dug a bit deeper into their pockets. Mohaka, Raupunga, Wairoa, Mahia and every other little town in our area helped to vote for Rongo and thats why he got in. SIMPLE AS THAT!! YIhaaaaaaaaaaaaa GO RONGO!!!!!!!
So he got through because he
So he got through because he had a bigger fan base? even though Teresa was the better singer? Where's the fairness in that?
Yes he got through because
Yes he got through because he has a bigger fan base. Thats the whole point - more people voted for Rongo than for Teresa, therefore has more fans. Just because the judges think she is great doesn't mean that she will appeal to the voting public, and it's the public's opinions which count. I'm sure that Teresa's family and friends were voting for her as well. So maybe it's not fair, and maybe Teresa was better in YOUR opinion, and deserved to be in the top 10, but according to the people who voted, they thought Rongo should be there. Life goes on.
Just to be nit-picky, we
Just to be nit-picky, we can't conclude that "more people voted for Rongo than for Teresa" and that he "has more fans".
All we know is that more votes were cast for Rongo.
Has anyone else thought that
Has anyone else thought that maybe, in dissing [somewhat] popular performers, the judges are jepardising the chances of their favourites? :s
I mean, last week, they told Shelley she was 'going home', then she got through and Lissel missed out, then this week they went on about Rongo's song choice and how they wanted him to 'move on from the audition room', so he got through and Theresa missed out.
It was a pity Theresa didn't make it, but I'm still glad Rongo got through. Very suprised, but sooooo happy! :D
Rosita sang the same song in
Rosita sang the same song in the top 24 as her audition and no one pointed that out.
Can you please stop spelling
Can you please stop spelling Teresa with an h?
Argh this sucks! We so need
Argh this sucks! We so need more than 1 wildcard, because great people can still miss out with the system they have at the moment :(
I want a top twelve *sighs*
I want a top twelve *sighs*
I wonder if petitioning for
I wonder if petitioning for a Top 12 could work...
*scratches chin*
NAH. TVNZ = cheap.
Besides, I'm sick of
Besides, I'm sick of petitions. I used to love them. The Michaelboppers put me right off.
*upset* The wee ten-year-old
*upset*
The wee ten-year-old who was very excited by the prospect of me getting txted the results was extremely pleased Teresa didn't get through.
Thanks Dad, Nellie, and Phantz - Hayls slightly less as I don't like Rongo :P
Admin, you spelt Jesse wrong
Admin, you spelt Jesse wrong in the first paragraph. I demand a correction. LOL.
Oops. It's a wiki page
Oops. It's a wiki page though ;)
Is too. My bad. But still!
Is too. My bad.
But still! *shakes finger*
So all I can think of is
So all I can think of is either Teresa or Lissel will be the Ngaiire of NZ Idol!
Rongo deserves to go thru
Rongo deserves to go thru because his family and crop of friends backed him where it matters....by voting.
So those of you who reckon teresa should go thru should've backed her like I did. Now hope she is a wildcard with maselina, marcel, kevin, lissel, christina, Makanui and the other girl from invercargill.
I voted Teresa
I voted Teresa
If I was related to her sure
If I was related to her sure i'd vote for her more but I do need to pay my bills! I voted for her 3 times and although that's not much it's enough to moan that my fave didnt get through!
at least you voted that's
at least you voted that's the main thing singaboi
Maybe we should start a vote
Maybe we should start a vote for the worst Nellie HAHA Rongo comes to mind! I mean the voting has already turned to crap so lets make it worse
VOTE FILIPO (aka Rongo)
WEll if you only voted 3
WEll if you only voted 3 times for your favourite how could you possibly afford to vote for that. Go Rongo!!!
YES! It'll be American Idol
YES!
It'll be American Idol 4 and the Pillsbury Dough Boy aka Scott Savol all over again!
Hehe so it'll be VOTE FILIPO
Hehe so it'll be VOTE FILIPO SAVOL!
Oh My God! Disgusting! Rongo
Oh My God! Disgusting! Rongo so doesn't deserve to be instead of Teresa!
Now eitehr Lissell or Teresa will miss out on the Top 10.. when they should both be in it!
Why Should Jesse get in over
Why Should Jesse get in over either of them. I agree Teresa should have been in the Top !) but not at the exspence of Rongo. E ki ra!! Ana Kaitoa
I ACTUALLY WANTED RONGO
I ACTUALLY WANTED RONGO INSTEAD OF TERESA...I THOUGHT TERESA'S PERFORMANCE WAS SCARY.........LOL
Waaaaa - I wanted Teresa to
Waaaaa - I wanted Teresa to get in. Oh well, my other two picks got in. Go Nik & Jesse! Wooohooo!!!
Wow, what a shocker. WHen it
Wow, what a shocker. WHen it was down to Rongo and Teresa I was sooooooooooo sure Rongo was going home, and kinda wasn't paying attention when they said the last name, and then Rongo's name was said and I was like "WHAT??" As much as I love Rongo, I sooo thought Teresa was a sure thing!
Well, at least there's still a wildcard show! I'm sure the judges will pick her as one of the 8!
YAY GO RONGO!!! Shame about
YAY :D
GO RONGO!!!
Shame about Teresa though :(
Im sorry but that has been
Im sorry but that has been the worst decision by the public since Filipo
OMG last week repeat... the
OMG last week repeat... the person with the better voice misses out. GHEY!
Oh well, as long as Niks there :D
YAY! JESSE!
YAY! JESSE!
teresa should have gone
teresa should have gone through. end. this show sucks now
I am shaking with shock and
I am shaking with shock and excitement.
I didn't like Teresa AND SHE DIDN'T GET THROUGH. *cackles evily*
OMG Rongo is the new
OMG Rongo is the new filipo...dumbface. I want Teresa :s
BAY WE DONT WANT TERESA BACK
BAY WE DONT WANT TERESA BACK ON HEA SHE SUX RONGO'S WAY BETTA DEN HER
I think that Makanui and
I think that Makanui and Theresa should have got through... Grr.
Nik is such a hottie!
There is no justice in the
There is no justice in the world. This is the problem when the judges do not pick a wildcard. The public are stupid, and have no appreciation of talent.
Meh.
that sucks so bad, where is
that sucks so bad, where is Theresa
Could someone please txt me
Could someone please txt me who gets through? I shall miss it and real!Dad's being a stinge and not txting me.