Episode Guide

Group 2 - Performance Show - Live Recap

Submitted by alcatel on 31 July, 2005 - 8:24pm.

The judges are introduced with incredibly lame jokes. Paul says he wants to encourage the Top 24 contestants.

Group 2 arrive at the house and get into the food straight away. There's a big pool out the back and a nice back yard.

Saelyn chose her name out of the hat first - she had a gut feeling she'd be up first. She looks beautiful in a red top. She sings "I Feel The Earth Move" - she's a good performer and works the camera well.  Frank wasn't sure about the song choice but he likes her "adventurous" "soulful" voice. Jackie loves her edge but not the song. Paul adds his little pop history speil - he can't stand her song choice, I'm tired of his music trivia.

Daniel Bell is up singing "Virtual Insanity" by Jamiroquai... he is even dressing the part... I'm scared. Daniel shows us the holes in his socks and says he could try out for handstand idol. Unfortunately he just can't pull it off for me. Oops, he missed a few lines... To be honest, I'm glad that's over. Paul said he blew it missing out the words, Paul says his voice isn't strong enough. Frankie liked his quirkiness. Jackie says there's something about him but didn't think he kicked it enough tonight.

Rick chooses to sing "This Love" by Maroon 5. His family are supporting him hard. He's loved the experience so far - although he's not sure about the hair straightening. His voice seems very average to me and I went to sleep a little during the performance. Jackie says he's a natural on stage but says he'll appeal more to the mums than the teenage girls out there. Frankie says it's just bland and not inspiring but he can sing and looks good. Paul liked the song choice and thinks he's good - he looks at the other judges like "nyeh nyeh nyeh".

Lissel says her name is actually a nickname which comes from the name Melissa. She's singing "Chains" by Tina Arena. She's wearing very gypsy-like clothing. I don't like the stud under her lip. She hits all the big notes well and I think she's got a good chance of going through to the Top 10. Frank said there was nothing bland about that performance and she has a very expressive face. Paul says it was "nifty, neato, swell". Jackie says she totally rocks.

Rosita is up next. We learn she's a debt collector, fun fun! I don't like her outfit at all. She's singing "I Have Nothing" by Whitney Houston. Now we'll hear "the note". Her voice is amazing - but I wonder if she has more in her to give. The tone is beautiful. Paul wonders if she's holding back and wants to see her grow. Jackie says it's great but wants to see more from her. Frankie wants more edge from her in time.

Shelley sings "Saving All My Love for You" by Whitney Houston. She has three kids. Wow - her hair looks beautiful straightened and coloured!!! She could do a shampoo ad. She sounds nice but is it enough? Oopsie, she missed the last note and had to try again... she's a smoker. Paul says it's the end of the road for her. Frankie says he's heard her sing it better. She's had a sore throat all day.

Mathew says he likes to tap dance. He's singing "When The War Is Over" by Cold Chisel. He's got straight and shiny hair. He's got a lovely voice and sounds fantastic. Frankie says he can sing. Jackie he has a really great voice but asks him to keep his moves simple. Paul says he's a NZ Idol geek and to think outside the world of "www.mathew"????!!! Paul's comment was totally uncalled for and a personal insult nothing to do with his performance or voice.

Ashley looks a little like Katie Holmes... sings "Love Really Hurts Without You" by Billy Ocean. I'm a little bored by her performance... it's a bit of a nothing song. The judges criticise her song choice.

»

xXx_bLaCk_BeTtY_xXx 1 August, 2005 - 4:49pm

I voted for shelly rosita lissel and ashley!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Girls rocked last night

™®»©ÜмĢ... 31 July, 2005 - 10:52pm

Thanks for the Recap... I hope they show what paul said tomorrow!

Random_Guy 31 July, 2005 - 10:14pm

Personally my top 3 would be:

Lissel            Rosita          Mathew          with Ashley in the 4th place

chevy 31 July, 2005 - 10:13pm
Nokia N95 theme

Lissel, Rosita and Ashley.

Texas 31 July, 2005 - 10:11pm
People are difficult to govern because they have t

My Top 3 would be Saelyn, Rosita and Ashley! My alternate is Lissel.

SingaBoi 31 July, 2005 - 10:09pm

Saelyn ~ I Feel The Earth Move - Carole King - I like this girls voice and pressence and was expecting big things when she nailed that Celine song in the theatre round! She was good but I do think it was the song choice and that it wasnt recent more that it wasnt the RIGHT song for her to sing. I still believe she pulled it off with her performance: 8/10

Daniel Bell ~ Virtual Insanity - Jamiroquai - This guy was boring me to death i mean it was just mumbled to me and not very memorable! Then he forgot the words and i think it just went down hill from there on: 5/10

Rick ~ This Love - Maroon 5 - Of the guys he was the best but that isnt exactly a good thing he did it nicely but that was kind of it you know? There was no 'edge' (stealing judges word) and he kinda bored me but his voice is good: 7.5/10

Lissel ~ Chains - Tina Arena - When I saw this girl sing in the theatre rounds i thought she was quite bad and yet she made it this far but tonight she totally blew me away with her impressive vocals and performance. I apologise to her for not giving her a shot because now I see what the judges saw WOW!: 9.5/10

Rosita ~ I Have Nothing - Whitney Houston - YAY she got to finish that note! Her performance wasnt as powerful as Lissel but she has one of the best voices in the competition for sure! This girl has alot more to show then this: 8.5/10

Shelley ~ Saving All My Love For You - Whitney Houston - I admire this girl she has 3 children and is only 23 and has an amazing voice! She woke up with a sore throat and still produced something quite amazing and if it wasnt for the last note she missed it would have been a raw emotional ride for me: 8/10

Mathew ~ When The War Is Over - Cold Chisel - Our own MattyJ!!!! But why did you pick a song that cant be touched anymore now that it's Cosima's song and unless you can show us the emotion she gave it just wont work out for you! As a fellow 'Idol Geek'  I think your voice was almost flawless but had no emotion (hey you did better then i could lol) but you should'nt have touched this: 7/10

Ashley ~ Love Really Hurts Without You by Billy Ocean - I thought she was funky and interesting and could definitely SING! I think she was the weakest of the girls but she is very pretty! Some of her words were interestingly said lol: 7/10

My top 4:
Lissel
Rosita
Saelyn
Shelley

NZ Top 4:
Lissel
Rosita
Saelyn
Rick

Who I think should go through:
Lissel, Rosita & Shelley

NZ will probably put through:
Lissel, Rosita & Rick

Eden Nightside 31 July, 2005 - 11:14pm

I'm glad I'm not the only one who though Shelley was good even though she had that little oopsiedaisy at the end.

I'm also glad you didn't place Ashley in your top 4.

But then again I am your mistress. Winky wink. Laughing out loud

SingaBoi 31 July, 2005 - 11:17pm

Yes you are but she also is my 5th fave Smiling:)

alcatel 31 July, 2005 - 9:57pm

Yep am in agreement with u eastside, my picks for this week - Rosita, Lissel and a toss-up between Saelyn, Ashley  & Rick whose voices I all like, even tho the girls picked the wrong songs.

dirrtyidol 31 July, 2005 - 10:09pm

I agree with all your choices, except Rick. His voice is hardly strong enough!!! 

Jemma 31 July, 2005 - 9:40pm
Luvzy//

*claps for Matty*

Blah on Toast 31 July, 2005 - 9:38pm
Sup g.

Top 3 for me (hey I rhyme): Lissel, Mathew and Rosita.

IdolJamie 31 July, 2005 - 9:59pm

My favourites too, but this week is gonna be a pretty strong top 4 I think.

~Groovy Bex~ 31 July, 2005 - 9:40pm

Ditto Jessie Smiling

eastsideforlife 31 July, 2005 - 9:35pm

big upzz to the top 24, it takes alot of courage to get up in front of new zealand and sing..big upz to the 3 that have made it so far....ROSITA...damn, you got our votes girl!!!!   GO HARD AND LET THE BEAUTY WITHIN SHINE....

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Episode Guide

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 11 guests online.